What ought?

Friday, September 6, 2024

[[]]

Many thoughts in my head after watching some gary's economics youtube and reawakening thinking about wealth and inequality (but now with a bit more tax experience).

1. Singapore is very correct to pay political decision makers a high salary.
From PSD, Singapore benchmarks to top 1,000 salary earners in Singapore. Based on some simple deductions, an entry level minister earns 60% of what the 500th highest salary earner in Singapore earns and the prime minister earns 120% of what the 500th highest salary earner in Singapore, paid in a clean wage (see our minister Iswaran's corruption case for example).
The stated goals are to attract talent, to prevent corruption and to have fair remuneration for the responsibilities and work done. I think these are all well and good.

However, incidentally and perhaps more importantly, the salary sizing serves to:
a. Make up a large proportion of the office holder's income (this not only prevents corruption in the common sense where the office holder has to find other income sources to supplement their income, but it also prevents corruption in the other sense where an office holder's main income is from other sources e.g passive from already being rich or having a rich spouse (see Rishi Sunak))
b. Align the interests of the political decision makers to the employment class by making them part of the employment class (albeit at the highest end)
c. Places the job in the realm of "aspirational employment wealth" which is "attainable" by many people if they are smart and hardworking. 
d. Allows the political decision maker to hold the same amount of "power" through salary / wealth / money as the rich, who they are interacting with, i.e doesn't disadvantage them on a social standpoint and/or make them need external wealth to match the social wealth related standing. (see Jerome Powell's 200k salary while setting policy affecting billions and billionaires)
e. Doesn't overstretch the "discount" for public service ethos. (40% discount on the median of the median 1,000 salary earners because they are in the job for "public good")
f. Ideally it is stressful enough such that a very wealthy person (e.g 100+ million dollars wealth) will never choose to do it for personal gain (over public gain) while offering sufficient personal gain for the capable but not very wealthy

2. The tax code's distinction between capital and income is very abusable by the rich. It seems to me that labour derived income and capital derived income will catch the rich much better (to split income tax). On top of that, there should be certain capital / wealth taxes in itself.

a. Capital gains tax (the most prevalent form of capital derived income tax) is essentially useless if the rich can take a loan against their asset and defer the sale of the asset forever (especially if there is remission or equivalent of capital gains at death). To elaborate a bit more, this control over when to be taxed is OP and shouldn't be allowed. Presumably this was done due to liquidity but for income-derived illiquid things like stock options are also taxed upon receiving control and you have control over your capital gain.
b. Rental income / dividends income, in my opinion, should be considered capital - derived income.
c. Tricky to tax unearned capital gains or maybe a matter of political will? - if they can take loan to get liquidity without selling to avoid capital gains they could take a loan to pay taxes but of course they don't want to)
d. Corporate income tax, especially 1 tier corporate income tax is technically also capital - derived income. This is as the gains accrue to the shareholders essentially who have only contributed capital (they should be remunerated with a salary / director fee if they act in other capacity)

With this "grouping", you can then see the net rates of taxes in capital derived income vs labor derived income. If you want to cover land and entrepreneurship, you can put land pretty much into capital and entrepreneurship into labor since the remuneration would be labor derived.

[[I wrote this at]]*|12:13 AM|

[[The Undead]]

Ashraf
Boon Pin
Francis
Huiting
Hsiao Ching
Labigail
Shaun Lee
Ting Yit
Wee Wei Ming
Xiao Qi

[[Book wishlist (lend me pls)]]

A Lover's Discourse: Fragments (Barthes)
How to read a book (Adler)
Cost of discipleship (Bonhoeffer)
Crime and Punishment (Dostoyevsky)

[[The Story Thus]]

|January 2008|February 2008|March 2008|April 2008|May 2008|June 2008|July 2008|August 2008|September 2008|October 2008|November 2008|December 2008|January 2009|February 2009|March 2009|April 2009|May 2009|June 2009|July 2009|August 2009|September 2009|October 2009|November 2009|December 2009|January 2010|February 2010|March 2010|April 2010|May 2010|June 2010|July 2010|August 2010|September 2010|October 2010|November 2010|December 2010|January 2011|February 2011|March 2011|April 2011|May 2011|June 2011|July 2011|August 2011|September 2011|October 2011|November 2011|December 2011|January 2012|February 2012|March 2012|April 2012|May 2012|June 2012|July 2012|August 2012|September 2012|October 2012|November 2012|December 2012|January 2013|February 2013|March 2013|April 2013|May 2013|June 2013|July 2013|August 2013|September 2013|October 2013|November 2013|December 2013|January 2014|February 2014|March 2014|April 2014|May 2014|June 2014|July 2014|August 2014|September 2014|October 2014|November 2014|December 2014|January 2015|February 2015|March 2015|April 2015|May 2015|June 2015|July 2015|August 2015|September 2015|October 2015|November 2015|December 2015|January 2016|February 2016|March 2016|April 2016|May 2016|June 2016|July 2016|August 2016|September 2016|October 2016|November 2016|December 2016|January 2017|February 2017|March 2017|April 2017|May 2017|June 2017|July 2017|August 2017|September 2017|October 2017|November 2017|December 2017|January 2018|February 2018|March 2018|April 2018|May 2018|June 2018|July 2018|August 2018|September 2018|October 2018|November 2018|December 2018|January 2019|February 2019|March 2019|April 2019|May 2019|June 2019|July 2019|August 2019|September 2019|October 2019|November 2019|December 2019|January 2020|February 2020|March 2020|April 2020|May 2020|June 2020|July 2020|August 2020|September 2020|October 2020|November 2020|December 2020|January 2021|February 2021|March 2021|April 2021|May 2021|June 2021|July 2021|August 2021|September 2021|October 2021|November 2021|December 2021|January 2022|February 2022|March 2022|April 2022|May 2022|June 2022|July 2022|August 2022|September 2022|October 2022|November 2022|December 2022|January 2023|February 2023|March 2023|April 2023|May 2023|June 2023|July 2023|August 2023|September 2023|October 2023|November 2023|December 2023|January 2024|February 2024|March 2024|April 2024|May 2024|June 2024|July 2024|August 2024|September 2024|October 2024

[[The Talk (also silent)]]

[[The Ancients]]

Gillian
Fwoooooosh
Amel
Bernice
Beverly
Chiable
Desmond
James
Jiayun
Jocelyn
The /ksl
Michael
Nich Lam
Nich lim
Priscilla
Rebecca
Tony
Vanessa
Ying Xuan
Yong Jian
Zhi Ling
302
CMI
Sister
Alvin
Joshua
[[Credits]]

|Blogskins|
|Blogger|